Foucault News

Leonard D’Cruz, The Limits of Radical Historicism: The Methodological Significance of Foucault’s Relationship to Transcendental Philosophy, Angelaki, 29(6), 2024, 53–76.

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1080/0969725X.2024.2430899

Abstract:
This article examines the methodological significance of Foucault’s relationship to transcendental philosophy. While Foucault presents his work as a historicist transformation of Kant’s critical project, some commentators question whether he succeeds in eradicating the transcendental dimension of critique. In this way, they raise doubts over whether he can sustain his methodological commitment to radical historicism. In response, I argue that Foucault can reflexively account for his use of transcendental motifs while remaining faithful to his historicist methodology. More specifically, I show how the concept of sedimentation can give coherence to the supposedly paradoxical notion of the historical a priori. Furthermore, I demonstrate that Foucault’s ostensibly transcendental assumptions about power and subjectivity are best understood as contingent features of his analytical framework rather than earnest metaphysical claims.

Keywords:
Foucault genealogy transcendental critique historical a priori sedimentation

Ratcliffe, J.
Genealogy: A conceptual map (2024) European Journal of Philosophy

DOI: 10.1111/ejop.12949

Abstract
The blossoming literature on genealogy in recent years has come as somewhat of a pleasant surprise to the historically inclined among us. It has not, however, come without its difficulties. As I see it, the literature on genealogy is guilty of two conflations, what I call the “debunking/problematizing conflation” and the “problematizing/rationalizing conflation.” Both are the result of the inadequate typological maps currently used to organize the literature. As a result, what makes many genealogies philosophically interesting often remains obscure. In response, I propose a new two-dimensional typology that avoids these conflations and outfits us with a richer conceptual vocabulary with which to understand and organize the genealogies which populate the literature. By identifying a second dimension of analysis which has thus far gone untheorized, my typology enables us to elucidate the various normative objectives and objects of investigation structuring a literature which is more diverse than previously acknowledged. We can thus get a clearer understanding of the problems those genealogies face, of their critical potential, and of their implications for our conception of critique. © 2024 The Authors. European Journal of Philosophy published by John Wiley & Sons Ltd.

Author Keywords
background frameworks; Brandom; debunking; debunking/problematizing conflation; Foucault; genealogy; genetic fallacy; problematizing; problematizing/rationalizing conflation; rationalizing; self-defeat; two-dimensional typology; vindicatory; Wittgenstein

Bigoni, M., Maran, L., Occhipinti, Z.
Of power, knowledge and method: The influence of Michel Foucault in accounting history
(2024) Accounting History

DOI: 10.1177/10323732241243088

Abstract
Michel Foucault’s work had a strong influence not only in philosophy but also in a wide range of humanistic and social disciplines, including accounting. Notably, the first studies which brought Foucault’s thought to the attention of interdisciplinary accounting scholars were historical. This article documents how Foucault’s ideas have directly inspired accounting history scholars, how the latter have interpreted and brought Foucault’s work into their field as well as what future research paths may lie ahead. The article offers a systematisation of how the complex ideas of Foucault have been translated into eight key themes that have provided a crucial interpretive prism to many studies in accounting history. In doing so, it assists scholars wishing to familiarise themselves with Foucault’s work and employ it in their research. © The Author(s) 2024.

Author Keywords
accounting history; Foucault; interdisciplinary; knowledge; literature review; power

Wang, C., Wang, S.
Educating the Autonomous Learner in a Confucian School: Subjectivity, Memorisation, and Dilemma
(2023) China Perspectives, 2023 (135), pp. 61-70.

Abstract
The current literature on Chinese governmentality and subjectivity lacks rigorous discussion of the involvement of Confucian education. This article applies Foucauldian conceptual tools to explore this scholarship gap empirically. Based on ethnographic fieldwork at a Confucian school, we explore how Confucian pedagogical techniques are used to create a type of subject. This article first presents pedagogical reform in a Confucian school. The resultant pedagogy of individualised memorisation combines two paradoxical knowledge sources: the individualised teaching principle and the method of repetitive memorisation. We then demonstrate how the Confucian teaching techniques used in the classroom result in contradictory processes of subject-making. Students are governed by the technologies of power in the disciplined classroom but are also encouraged to be the “master” of their own study according to the technologies of the self, so as to become autonomous learners. The revived Confucian education is encountering a profound cultural dilemma between autonomy/individuality and coercion/authority in the making of subjects. © 2023, Francais sur la Chine Contemporaine China. All rights reserved.

Author Keywords
Confucian education; Foucault; governmentality; power; subjectification