Was there a theological turn in phenomenology? (2018)

Leask, I.
Was there a theological turn in phenomenology?
(2018) Philosophy Today, 62 (1), pp. 149-162.

DOI: 10.5840/philtoday201837205

Abstract
This article examines the possibility that phenomenology was “always already” a theological enterprise, by outlining some of the foundational criticisms levelled by Michel Foucault and Louis Althusser. For both thinkers, the phenomenological stress on “lived experience” grants an undue primacy to the realm of “interiority”; as a result, subjectivity is left, not just reified, but also deified. By contrast, both Foucault and Althusser will argue for understanding the subject as constituted rather than constitutive; philosophy’s task, accordingly, is to delineate the broader structures (economic, ideological, discursive, linguistic, etc.) that create “lived experience,” rather than to hypostatize the subject as the privileged bearer of logos. As well as outlining the contours of this critique, however, the article indicates some of the shortcomings entailed in a total disavowal of “lived experience.” © 2018. Philosophy Today, Volume 62, Issue 1 (Winter 2018).

Author Keywords
” anti-humanism; “theological turn; Althusser; Foucault; Phenomenology; Spinoza